Page 1 of 2

#1 - May 3 2018

Posted: Thu May 03, 2018 10:35 pm
by Brain
All Runs:
may 3 18 results.png
may 3 18 results.png (30.62 KiB) Viewed 9080 times
Top Gun Results:
may 3 18 tg results.png
may 3 18 tg results.png (9.18 KiB) Viewed 9080 times
Results:
may 3 18 all.png
may 3 18 all.png (46.79 KiB) Viewed 9080 times

Re: #1 - May 3 2018

Posted: Thu May 03, 2018 10:42 pm
by Brain
PAX All Drivers:
may 3 18 pax all.png
may 3 18 pax all.png (40.54 KiB) Viewed 9078 times
RAW All Drivers:
may 3 18 raw all.png
may 3 18 raw all.png (40.44 KiB) Viewed 9078 times

Re: #1 - May 3 2018

Posted: Thu May 03, 2018 11:03 pm
by Brain
Questions, comments, classing changes, name spelling..........ask away or pm me....

A couple things I'm still considering if anyone has any input.....

- Changing the scoring to 10 points for a win instead of 100 which should tighten the competition, but increases the chances of ties.

- the "Rob Rule" :lol: - at what point do we bump someone into top gun if they are regularly winning overall top pax ahead of the top gun drivers. I'm thinking something like 3 overall PAX wins gets you bumped to top gun and then the results are recalculated for all previous events reflecting that move. That's a whole lot of work, but the intention is to create competition in the larger group and if someone is dominating then they should be in top gun....

PM me if you have thoughts, but don't want to make your opinions public.

Re: #1 - May 3 2018

Posted: Fri May 04, 2018 12:04 am
by mcsinc
I think 3 wins = bump is a good idea.
How about 3 bottom placings in top gun = bump the other way ?

Thought of a name for the second group?

Good choice of course layout for the season opener!

Nice driving for someone without a chance of winning. :shock:

Re: #1 - May 3 2018

Posted: Fri May 04, 2018 7:45 am
by SkinnyG
I wouldn't mind seeing a "Novice Series" for folks in their first year. It might hold people who are just trying it out, but leave because they are nowhere near winning. I don't know how easy that would be logistically....

Re: #1 - May 3 2018

Posted: Fri May 04, 2018 8:48 am
by Brain
mcsinc wrote:How about 3 bottom placings in top gun = bump the other way ?
It was sort of the intention that you win and you go to top gun forever. So if you had a closed sample group eventually everyone would get the trophy in the main group. Of course in reality there's always new people and only one person moves to top gun each year meaning the "yet unnamed" group will likely always remain the largest and be very competitive.
mcsinc wrote:Thought of a name for the second group?
Nope - open to suggestions. I've heard of clubs using Top Dog and Underdog or Pro and Amateur or "Best of the Rest", but those sound demeaning. The intent is actually the opposite - we want top gun to be the outcasts and the main group to be the standard :lol:
mcsinc wrote:Nice driving for someone without a chance of winning. :shock:
I was shocked - I was pretty sure Rob was untouchable. Hence the question of the "Rob Rule" - I think it's quite possible that he could win top gun
SkinnyG wrote:I wouldn't mind seeing a "Novice Series" for folks in their first year. It might hold people who are just trying it out, but leave because they are nowhere near winning. I don't know how easy that would be logistically....
Yes - we've talked about a novice series before. From a scoring perspective I can make it happen quite easily. We usually come up with 2 issues:

#1 - We don't necessarily have enough people to count only first year people. Being #1 when only 2 novices have enough events doesn't seem worth the effort. Maybe first two years?

#2 - Counting 75% of the events doesn't work so well for people that start part way through the year. Maybe count 40% of the total events? Or minimum 5 events and use average score? Or just best 5 races? I sort of prefer just best 5 races (or 6? Or 7?) because it does somewhat favor those who attend more events.

Anybody have thoughts/suggestions? Post or PM me....

Re: #1 - May 3 2018

Posted: Fri May 04, 2018 12:13 pm
by Hamshonads
Brain wrote:I was shocked - I was pretty sure Rob was untouchable. Hence the question of the "Rob Rule" - I think it's quite possible that he could win top gun
Ohh i dunno about that..

But i hope i can put the "rob rule" in effect! :lol:

Re: #1 - May 3 2018

Posted: Fri May 04, 2018 5:04 pm
by mcsinc
mcsinc wrote:How about 3 bottom placings in top gun = bump the other way ?
I was actually just kidding -- typing on a teeny iphone at 12 AM apparently doesn't work that well. lol

Novices - best 5 sounds good. If they haven't done 5 and come out the following year, they can be eligible for that year.

Is it just me or does Hamshonads remind you of another young guy who started a few years ago and started destroying everyone with alien driving skillz :o

p.s Hamshonads - what kind of name is that ?! anagram??

Re: #1 - May 3 2018

Posted: Fri May 04, 2018 7:08 pm
by Hamshonads
mcsinc wrote:p.s Hamshonads - what kind of name is that ?! anagram??

It was supposed to be hamiltons hondas and it kind of morphed into hamshonads and stuck :?

Re: #1 - May 3 2018

Posted: Mon May 07, 2018 9:53 am
by brucethebrat
I like the idea of bumping up a 3 time winner. We will have to discuss the name of the "also rans" over beer/coke next Thursday.